← TrendWatcher
Hacker News
5/10

Big Manuscript Stress Test

A free web tool where novelists, journalists and screenwriters paste or upload their in-progress manuscript and instantly see whether their current writing app (Scrivener, Ulysses, Google Docs, Word) will slow down, lag or crash on that file size.

Target user

Authors and long-form writers shopping for a writing app that won't buckle on their book

Features
  • Upload your .docx, .md, or .fountain file and get a 'stress score' for 8 popular writing apps
  • Side-by-side scroll, search, undo-redo and find-and-replace latency simulation
  • Recommendations for splitting strategy (chapter splits, library structure) before you commit to a tool
  • Optional weekly re-test to track manuscript growth vs app performance
Why now

The Moby Dick workout idea is gaining traction among indie writers burned by Ulysses-style slowdowns mid-novel; there is no neutral, manuscript-shaped benchmark for non-coders to lean on.

Signals · overall 5/10
Demand
5/10

Real but niche pain: third-party review explicitly warns 'Google Docs lags significantly once a document passes 50 pages' and Ulysses has dedicated complaint threads; Moby Dick workout HN trend referenced in the brief returned zero search hits, suggesting the 'why now' hook is weaker than claimed.Scrivener Review (2026): Why It Beats Google Docs (Real Test)Ulysses app not working? crashes or has problems? - JustUseApp

Whitespace
7/10

No dedicated, neutral manuscript-size benchmark tool surfaces across searches; the closest substitutes are ad-hoc blog reviews that test one scenario (e.g. a 60k-word manuscript), leaving an open lane for a purpose-built tool.Scrivener Review 2025: An Expert Breakdown for WritersScrivener Review (2026): Why It Beats Google Docs (Real Test)

Monetization
3/10

Hard to monetize a free tool aimed at a niche; Scrivener charges ~$60 one-time and Ulysses/Word run on subscriptions, so affiliate/lead-gen to writing apps is plausible but conversion volumes for indie novelists shopping for apps are low.Scrivener Review (2026): Why It Beats Google Docs (Real Test)Scrivener: The #1 Writing Software for Mac, Windows & iPad

Longevity
6/10

Long-form writers have always outgrown word processors and the upgrade treadmill (new Scrivener iOS, Ulysses subscriptions, Docs features) means the 'will my app cope at 200k words' question keeps recurring.Scrivener: The #1 Writing Software for Mac, Windows & iPad

Feasibility
4/10

Trivial-sounding but actually hard: a pure web tool cannot run Scrivener/Ulysses/Word on the user's device, so it must reduce to file-size heuristics or a downloadable desktop agent — either path adds friction vs. the 'paste and see' promise.Scrivener Review (2026): Why It Beats Google Docs (Real Test)

Moby Dick Workout (2022) · 51 points · 16 commentsHacker News · 2026-07-05 (19d ago)